Clique em uma foto para ir ao Google Livros
Carregando... The Brothers Karamazov (Bantam Classics) (original: 1880; edição: 1984)de Fyodor Dostoevsky, Andrew R. MacAndrew (Tradutor), Konstantin Mochulsky (Introdução)
Informações da ObraOs Irmãos Karamazóv de Fyodor Dostoevsky (1880)
Favourite Books (48) » 88 mais Out of Copyright (8) 19th Century (15) Books Read in 2017 (172) Five star books (154) Top Five Books of 2014 (186) Folio Society (403) Books Read in 2022 (858) Books Read in 2016 (2,550) CCE 1000 Good Books List (255) Story Within a Story (14) Existentialism (16) The Greatest Books (54) Política - Clásicos (156) Fiction For Men (74) Fake Top 100 Fiction (62) AP Lit (336) Romans (21) Books on my Kindle (114) SHOULD Read Books! (187) Books Read in 2014 (2,187) I Can't Finish This Book (148) Unread books (821) Carregando...
Registre-se no LibraryThing tpara descobrir se gostará deste livro.
My goodness but those 19th-century Russian authors were verbose! ( ) Dieses Buch, das mächtigste von Swetlana Geiers "Fünf Elefanten" ( https://5elefanten.ch/en/film) - so nannte sie ihre Übersetzungen der fünf großen Dostojewskij Romane- begleitete mich über 3 Monate. Ich hatte Die Brüder Karamasow mehrmals in meinem Leben begonnen, nie gelang es mir, mehr als einige Kapitel zu lesen; jetzt schaffte ich es, und nicht nur dies: nach dem 'Großinquisitor', begann ich es von neuem, und später noch einmal blätterte ich zurück, beides mal, um mir Einzelheiten wieder ins Gedächtnis zu rufen: die Gespräche und emotionellen Reaktionen, die Sprache, die die Menschen denkend und handelnd lebendig erstehen lässt. Dieser Roman stellt große Ansprüche: Du must dir Zeit und Konzentration zum Lesen lassen, jeden Satz kosten und im Gedächtnis behalten - und bereit sein zurückblättern. Das Deutsch der Svetlana Geier ist großartig! Sie fügt hilfreiche Anmerkungen zum Verständnis bei, auch ein Namenverzeichnis der wichtigsten Personen: russische Namen sind für uns nicht leicht zu behalten (den junge Kalganow, Miussows Neffe - zum ersten Mal tritt er im Achten Buch auf - vermisste ich). Ich machte mir einige Notizen: Nadryw (4. Buch, Anm. zu S.263) - SG nennt es: 'eine willentlich Selbstzerstörung als Bestätigung der Freiheit des Individuums'. Anm. zu S.239: der Besuch Gruschenkas bei Katerina Iwanowna gehöre zu den "Duellen der Königinnen" in Dostojewskijs Werk in Anklang an Schillers 'Maria Stuart', schreibt SG. Iwan: "…wenn es keinen Gott gäbe, müßte man ihn erfinden" (377f) Iwan: "ein Unschuldiger darf für einen Schuldigen nicht bestraft werden (383) "die bestialische Grausamkeit des Menschen ist … beleidigend für die Bestien [!!] "… wenn der Mensch den Teufel geschaffen, so hat er ihn nach seinem Bilde geschaffen (384) "… in jedem Menschen lauert eine Bestie, die Bestie des … (389) Iwan: " Ich will keine Harmonie, aus Liebe zur Menschheit will ich keine Harmonie. Lieber bleibe ich bei meinem ungerächten Leid und meinem ungestillten Zorn, … (395) Der Starez Sossima über 'Freiheit': "Indem die Freiheit als … möglichst rasche Befriedigung ihrer Bedürfnisse verstanden wird, entstellen die Menschen ihre wahre Natur, … (505f) Wir, die wir Deutsch lesen, können uns glücklich schätzen, diese Übersetzung bekommen zu haben. This novel has been profoundly instrumental in the shaping of my own existential philosophy and Christian faith, perhaps more than any other, and easily falls into my top ten favourite novels. On the surface, the plot is quite simple and it contains two primary aspects: one is a drama of patricide and the other is the conflicting development of three brothers, the libertine, the intellectual and the faithful. But underneath all of this, and what determines the actions of the characters, is the philosophical ideology which Dostoevsky expresses primarily in the renowned essay, "The Grand Inquisitor", which is a masterpiece of writing in and of itself. It is as a result of these findings that we are invited into the unique psyches of our characters to find out what determines each one's behaviour, and we are thus met with Dostoevsky's own view of life, expressed most acutely in the brothers' separate destinies. Thirty years ago, at the university, when I read this for the first time I was more interested in the philosophical lines of thought. This time, I was much more impatient with the characters in the novel. I had far less tolerance of their deep flaws. Thirty years ago, though I saw the tragedy in the characters I found emotional release and a kind of pleasure in experiencing the novel. This time I was kept thinking, "make it stop" Mitya is too much. Ivan is too much. Smerdyakov is just awful. This prosecutor is ridiculous. How long can this defense attorney drone on about nothing? Thirty years ago, the lesson of the triumph of child-like faith was mostly lost on me or at least I don't remember thinking about it. Ilyusha had not the smell of decay. The sure-Saint Zossima decayed prematurely. The simple and uncelebrated faith of a little boy received only the brief press of the author's comment. Alyosha and his band of boy disciples would swear to treaure his memory but the greater community might have forgotten him completely. Yet, this boys simple faith could conquer death and its stink. Only one boy received the rebuke of Alyosha. It was the one boy who wanted to grow up, who wanted to be a free thinking man before manhood. It was the teenage boy, Kolya, who tried to snuff out another boys significance, but was contradicted by Alyosha. Yet even he was affirmed as being fully significant in the eyes of God and fully eligable for a resurrection and reunion at the end of the age. A beautiful, lengthy, difficult and rewarding novel. If I keep my wits I hope to read it a third time in this life. Pertence à série publicadaClube de Literatura Clássica (CLC) (37 [May 2023]) — 21 mais Everyman's Library (802-803) Great Books of the Western World (Volume 52, 1952 ed.) Modern Library (151) La nostra biblioteca Edipem (52-53) Está contido emGreat Books Of The Western World - 54 Volume Set, Incl. 10 Vols of Great Ideas Program & 10 Volumes Gateway To Great Books de Robert Maynard Hutchins (indireta) GREAT BOOKS OF THE WESTERN WORLD--54 Volumes 27 volumes 1961-1987 GREAT IDEAS TODAY (Yearbooks) 10 volumes GATEWAY TO THE GREAT BOOKS 10 volumes GREAT IDEAS PROGRAM. Total 101 Volumes. de Robert Maynard Hutchins (indireta) ContémTem a adaptaçãoÉ resumida emInspiradoTem como estudoTem um comentário sobre o textoTem um guia de estudo para estudantesPrêmiosDistinctionsNotable Lists
Classic Literature.
Fiction.
HTML: What is free will? Is redemption possible? Can logic help us answer moral questions? Renowned Russian novelist Fyodor Dostoyevsky tackles all of these topics and many more in this remarkable novel, widely regarded as one of the classic masterpieces of literature. Follow the Karamazov family through the travails that transpire after the murder of their father, and expand your intellectual horizons with a work that celebrated thinkers such as Einstein, Freud, and Pope Benedict XVI cite as one of their favorites. .Não foram encontradas descrições de bibliotecas. |
Current DiscussionsNenhum(a)Capas populares
Google Books — Carregando... GênerosClassificação decimal de Dewey (CDD)891.733Literature Literature of other languages Literature of east Indo-European and Celtic languages Russian and East Slavic languages Russian fiction 1800–1917Classificação da Biblioteca do Congresso dos E.U.A. (LCC)AvaliaçãoMédia:
|