2C

Should Stephen have told Rachel about Twisk?

Probably not since he does not understand why Eldritch is being so secretive. But I suspect there will be some love interest developing between Stephen and Rachel, so some basis for trust is needed.

I think Stephen should be keeping his own counsel. He doesn't know Rachel from Eve - he could be getting himself into hot water as it is from helping Eldritch: helping Rachel could double his troubles.

He was far too forthcoming with her. I think he's naive and allowing his attraction to her cloud his judgement.

I agree with Bluebird that Stephen should watch what he tells Rachel.

I think his attraction to Rachel is clouding his judgment. He doesn't know anything about her, or Eldritch either.

Very naive the way he has dealt with her, certainly shouldn't have revealed that so early in the proceedings.

I think he should have waited before telling her. He is so trusting with everyone it seems except his uncle.

He should be more careful with her. Not necessarily secretive, just selective about what he shares. After all, what does he really know about her?