This is like an adventure novel and a travel journal, boring at times, interesting and readable others. ( )

Classic read about the first major expedition of the Colorado river area. Great descriptions of the landscape and the adventures of the crew. Also interesting to read about the interaction of Powell and his team with local Indian tribes and description of their different cultures ( )

Though plain spoken in describing the portages in such canyons the immensity of the landscape and the task undertaken by Powell and his men permeated the read. Truly an awesome undertaken. And his descriptions of side canyons and Indians that inhabited these areas in the early 1870s were very interesting and unsentimental. A very enlightening though sometimes tedious read. ( )

Quite an interesting book, seeing that its more of a collection of writings that were originally written for a magazine. The first 100 pages focused on geography and seems more like nature writing. This part was a little slow and seemed that it was designed to inform casual readers on the east coast, who may not be as familiar with the western territories. It was 1870 after all.
The second and more quickly paced section of the book is the diary of J.W. Powell, but there are some points where it can be somewhat confusing because one of the other party members is also named Powell. The diary covers the first trip down the Green River and then the Colorado River through Glen Canyon and Grand Canyon. The third section of the book is really more of an ethnography than exploration and seems to be written in 1890, a good deal after the actual journey. In hindsight, Powell's outlook on the natives he encounters would seem archaic compared to modern anthropology, but given the time and circumstances, it was quite surprising to read his relatively modern views on the matter.
Overall, a nice edition to any exploration literature collection. It covers a lot of subjects and might not be for everyone, especially if your looking to read a book about a rafting trip and not a book about native story telling. ( )

John Wesley Powell's account of the first descent of the Colorado River and Grand Canyon by boat is generally considered canonical American exploration literature. To give some sense of its perceived importance, National Geographic in its list of 100 all time best adventure books ranks the Lewis and Clark journals as number 2, and Powell's book at number 4. The Grand Canyon itself ranks as one of the worlds greatest natural features, on par with the poles, Mount Everest and the Amazon - Powell's account likewise is lifted by the sheer magnificence of its discovery, the books literary qualities and story of sheer survival enhance it further.

The 1869 trip was largely funded with private money, and was supposed to have been a scientific journey of exploration. Because Powell lost in the rapids most of the science equipment, maps and records, he ended up writing most of the book years later in the first person for a wider non-scientific audience, based from his personal journal, memory and with some embellishments. Powell could be literary in his descriptions: "We think of the mountains as forming clouds about their brows, but the clouds have formed the mountains." Unfortunately the book is inconsistent and large sections contain geographic descriptions that can easily be skipped over since they were meant to be scientific, but are really more amateur science. Many of his analogies today seem dated, such as mountains with "gables" and "panels", imagery more meaningful to Victorian architecture, but this creates period atmosphere. As is usual in older exploration books, it needs a modern re-telling to fully understand and absorb the events from multiple perspectives, but reading the original account is the most authentic experience we have, short of running the river in person, which many still do with a copy of Powell's book on hand. I look forward to watching the 1999 PBS documentary done in a "Ken Burns" style with original photos, as well as the most recent and longest reconstruction Edward Dolnick's Down the Great Unknown (2001).

--Review by Stephen Balbach, via CoolReading (c) 2008 cc-by-nd ( )