J. N. D. KellyResenhas

interpretation/criticism

ANOTHER BOOK GIFTED TO ME BY MY BROTHER IN CHRIST AND FRIEND Keith Shull

A standard text hallowed by theological students for decades, this is an excellent reference and overview of the history of early Christian belief and doctrinal development. Dryly-written, restrained, and erudite, Kelly is a reliable scholar of the early Fathers and has earned the trust of generations of the faithful.

While this is a chronological listing of all the Popes (including the anti-Popes) with brief biographical details, The Oxford Dictionary of Popes reads at times like a rollercoaster novel, with plenty of salacious details.

With the Avignon schism at one stage you had three Popes running around, which could cause great financial stress to nobleman who were forced to entertain them at length. That would have been annoying.

I have to say I had a hard time attempting to choose my favourite Pope, although at a pinch I would state the chap that reigned for but an hour or so during a pitched battle and possibly wasn't even aware he was Pope during that time.½

A dictionary, so as such, not a book you read, though a well-laid out and evenhanded look at all of the heirs to St. Peter, as well as the Apostle himself. It would be interesting to see an updated entry on St. John Paul II, as well as Pius XII (given the recent shots taken at that pontiff). Pity there aren't illustrations.

About three-quarters of the way through Early Church Doctrines, the author makes this comment: "The student who seeks to understand [a particular doctrine] ... must be prepared to pick his way through a variety of theories, to all appearance unrelated and even mutually incompatible, existing side by side and sometimes sponsored by the same theologian." Realistically, though, most of the doctrines of the early church (the back of the book calls it "from the close of the apostolic age to the ... fifth century") could fit this statement.

This is not an easy book to wade through; it is not "Early Church Doctrine for Dummies." Some familiarity with the early church fathers is expected. Each two-page spread is almost guaranteed to have either Greek or Latin terms (sometimes both) on it, although most of those terms are briefly summarized. I had hoped for a little more hand-holding, but with so many different doctrines to summarize, there isn't much time for long introductions.

Assuming you are worthy to continue, there's a lot of information compressed into five hundred pages. There are the early debates on the Trinity and what "The Word" really means, and what the sacraments entail. There are the well-known early writers in church history (Tertullian and Clement and Origen and Ambrose and Augustine) and there were some who were new to me (Epiphanius and Theodoret). There are the early charges of heresy for various positions, sometimes to be subtly worked into church doctrine years later. With so many intertwining theories, I felt like I was jumping from rock to rock across a raging river, never quite getting my bearings. That's not the fault of the book, though; it's my own (non-)familiarity with the underlying concepts. It's a very good reference source (there are likely over a thousand footnotes to the original sources) that I hope someday to return to, this time with a stronger background in at least some of the topics.

---------------------------------------------------
LT Haiku:

Early church fathers
Developing doctrine for
The next thousand years.

an outstanding book, shockingly bound with the cheapest, nastiest glue I have ever encountered outside of Mills and Boon! C'mon, Harper & Row - this deserved better. (fortunately since replaced with a hardcover)

This book is a tour de force of early Christian beliefs. J.N.D. Kelly touches every major Father of the Church from the Apostolic Age to the 6th century as well as many relatively minor figures from the early Church. If you want to know what the early Christians believed, I highly recommend this book to you. I caution, though, that in order to get the most out of this book you must have a thorough knowledge of the history of Christianity for the first six centuries at least. This book is already 500 pages long, so there's little time for Kelly to stop along the way to explain historical developments. The book is not even done in chronological order other than perhaps separating the Apostolic Fathers and Apologists from the later Fathers into two different sections of the book; the primary division of the book, though, is thematic. Nonetheless -- read this book if you're interested in knowing what the earliest Christians believed!

Very useful and surprisingly readable.½

Except for the inclusion of the Vatican II anti-Popes, this book is a wonderful source for information about the Vicars of Christ's Church.

Great introduction.

Interesting book on a shadowy character from Christianity's long ago past. Never really heard of him until I read The Making of Europe where points out his enormous contribution to Christian religion. Although some of the issues in Jerome's have more or less been buried. It points to the struggles the church has in every generation. Jerome translated the Latin bible from the Hebrew original thus making it accessible to a wider audience, and enhancing the Latin language as a whole.

Classic reference book.

This book shows why doctrine matters and why it cannot be ignored by the theologian or pastor. Combined with "The Cruelty of Heresy," the scope of orthodoxy is better understood.

A beautifully written, clear, elegant biography of Saint Jerome, and his influence on all christians through his teachings and his shaping of the bible.

This is the life story of Saint John Chrhysostom.

Reprint. Orig. publ.: New York, NY : Harper, 1960

Reprint. Orig. publ.: London : A. & C. Black, 1969

Reprint. Orig. publ.: London : A. & C. Black, 1969

NT Comm

NT Comm

Bible, N.T. Commentary

Needed for AHOS, Unit 3, Patristics I, The Fathers of the Church during the First Five Hundred Years