bought this book in 2010, I think. I started reading it but abandoned it. I always intended to get back to it, one day. It took awhile, though. What spurred me was the fact that I decided to rebuy it in epub, to replace the pdf copy I bought in 2010. And I am glad I did.
One word can describe this book: Epic. At times, it felt almost like I was reading fantasy novel, with minium of magic. This isn't fantasy, but Historical fiction. This isn't my favorite genre, since it often involves bloody, gorefilled battles.. ( I know, I have probably read the wrong books). But this book were different. Oh, there were battles in it. What made me love this were the vivid settings, and the human characters.
The settings made me feel as if I were walking through Memphis, standing on the ship on the way to Gaza, feeling the wind tussling my hair. My heart ached everytime Barca lost one of his friends. The ache tenfolded when I realised the source of The Beast. At the start of the book he was almost a murdering machine. He live for battle. Yet through the book, he change. He starts to feel compassion. That change stems from Jauharah and her patience.
Jauharah... I wept for her. For her loss, for the pain she had suffered, and for the choices she had to make.
And Callianestes...I admired him for daring to what was right. Heck, I admired all the characters for their honor and courage.

The combination of the characters and the setting created a riveting tale, that I just couldn't put down. But, as I read it, I was reminded that history goes in circles, and that no civilisation last forever.

What I didn't like. I'll admit it. I wish there was a happy ending, since is Hasdrabal Barca and Jauharah had earned it. Yet, that would make it a romance, which this isn't.
Still, I'll definitely read more by Scott Oden in the future.
( )

This book quickly grabbed me and pulled me in. I loved Oden's description of Barca's rage and Barca's relationship with Jauharah. The final battle in the book was thrilling and very emotional. ( )

Unfortunately I gave up on this. I like historical fiction normally ( )

Good read. The creation of a new Hero in Hasdrabal Barca. The taming of the beast and the end of an empire collide to create a splendid tale. ( )

This was a disappointment.

Although Oden seems to have a grasp of the era, the book simply did not grap me. Perhaps because the author seemed never able to leave his own era behind (ahead?) and truly embrace the era in which his characters supposedly lived, breathed, fought, loved and died.

More Memphis on the Mississippi than Memphis on the Nile.

I will give his work another chance, however. There is a lot of ability, just not yet marshalled. ( )