Clique em uma foto para ir ao Google Livros
Carregando... The Queen of Dirt Island (2022)de Donal Ryan
Carregando...
Registre-se no LibraryThing tpara descobrir se gostará deste livro. Ainda não há conversas na Discussão sobre este livro. Mawkish and melodramatic. Donal Ryan has an ear for some of the idiosyncracies of how rural Irish people—particularly those of a certain age—talk, but his dialogue lacks subtlety and variation. The characters and their motivations rang increasingly false the more the book progressed. The ending made me want to throw the book at the wall. ( ) The Queen of Dirt Island follows the Aylward women who live in a rural, small town in Ireland — a circumstance that both makes and breaks them as a family. A book of two-page chapters, it comes across as a bit of collage leaving readers to fill in a lot of the spaces and connect the missing pieces, but ultimately tells a story of four generations of women who rely on each other to survive what life throws at them. Set in a small Irish village, Nenagh, four generations of Aylward women live loudly, argumentatively and with fierce love for each other, 'all wrapped up in one bundle'. Eileen Aylward married because she was pregnant and was disowned by her family and on the birth of her daughter, Saoirse, her husband was killed in a car accident. Her mother-in-law owned a farm but eventually came to live with them whilst her son ran it and together, the women lived their lives with traumas and heartaches but always with the love of and for each other. Even if it didn't sound like it most of the time. Boy could these women cuss. There is no doubt that this is a novel about women with the men often characterised as weak, not very clever, drippy, depressed, unable to live up to their father's expectations or angry and violent. Mary was the head of the family, straight-talking and loud and not afraid of what others thought of her or of Eileen her daughter-in-law raising a child without a man. Eileen lived up to her name Queen of Dirt Island, ready to attack anyone who hurt her daughter or Mary, on one occasion head-butting the girl who shouted at her daughter. She grew up with the rough and tumble of a brother that she fought with constantly, one time pushing him off the roof of the family barn, and whilst this violence is not on display often, every now and then it escapes. When Saoirse becomes pregnant Mary and Eileen decide that the house wasn't big enough and that they need an extension, a bedroom and toilet of her own. They can't afford it so ask the builder to teach them how to lay bricks and build it themselves. Her room a small bit crooked in the wall for all Mother's care with a plumb line. p126 Saoirse is the character that I think is the least well-developed, strangely as it becomes clear towards the end of the book that she is telling the story. She seems quite blank in her early years, doesn't know that she was raped even if she wasn't hurt. She certainly wasn't in any state to consent to sex. In a chapter entitled 'Immaculate' we get one sentence that is a page and three quarters long of Eileen's thoughts about her daughter's pregnancy. . . . the pregnant virgin, look out there, Mary, and see can you see the three wise fucking men coming down the hill with our gold and our fankincense and our fucking myrrh, look out and see can you see the Holy Spirit and the North Star, our lady is after having an immaculate conception and she's going to give birth to the king of all men . . . p74 Saoirse is desperate to be in love, falling for Josh who then asks her to write down all the stories that her Mother and Nana tell and pass them onto him so that he can turn them into a book. She does this but when she reads the book he has written finally comes to her senses and stands up for herself, horrified at the way the women have been depicted. I have only just finished reading a book about author's stealing stories from other people - A Ladder to the Sky by John Boyne - and thought here we go again. A woman written out of the story that she wrote by a man who was supposed to be her lover. These women live in a small world, never travelling far but have the richness of family life that so many people wish for. Pearl, however, lives a life they didn't, finishing school and going to college to train to be a teacher and then taking a year out in her second year to travel safe and secure in the love of the women back in Ireland. Written in short chapters or vignettes reminiscent of memories, the writing flows and descibes the life of the women particularly well. The dialogue between Mary and anyone is sharp and rather honest even though it is never demarcated with speech punctuation. Her mother then at the back door and the postman offering to lift the box in for her, and her mother saying it was okay, and the postman saying, Lift with your legs , not your back. Nana's voice then floating out from her perch by the living-room window. He's some feckin' know-it-all, wouldn't you think he'd lift it himself if he's such an expert, and the jolly postman smiling, winking, calling back from his cargo doors Hello Mrs Aylward! and Nana shouting back, Oh, hello, Francis, love, is it yourself? Tell your mother I was asking for her! p239 I read this book because it is our next book club choice and because I am going to hear Donal Ryan talk at Budleigh Salterton's Literary Festival. The Q Three generations of women live together: Nana, her daughter-in-law of her deceased son Eilene, and Saoirse Alyard, Eilene's teenage daughter. In a small town in Ireland, these women who yell at each other, call each other terrible names, and fight, love each other immensely through all sorts of trials. Each chapter is only two pages long and the story slowly unfolds revealing the pasts of each woman. Eileen's husband has been killed in an auto accident, but she remains with her mother-in-law, having been rejected by her family for marrying "beneath" herself. Saoirse finds herself pregnant after a one-time affair unleashing her mother's wrath, but when the baby is born, a fierce bond develops. The story is as much of a character study as plot although, Eileen's inheritance of some land plays a big part of the plot. It's funny in places, sad in others and a good read. Dirt Island refers to land that belonged to Eileen's parents; land that her brother Richard wants to steal from her.
Ryan's short chapters act as memories and moments filled with reflection, bursts of emotions, or, in some cases, mystery. Ending with Ryan's delightful wink to his readers, The Queen of Dirt Island is a touching tribute to the strength of motherhood, female companionship, healing, regret, and forgiveness. Ryan, who tells his story in brief, impressionistic chapters, is a gifted prose stylist and has a particular talent for capturing the language and rhythm of dialogue. The outwardly contentious but deeply loving relationship between Eileen and Mary feels particularly true to life. His decision to break the book up into short parts, though, can make the characters and their story feel distant.... Though these tragic moments are shocking, they are undercut by Ryan's impulse to have everyone get along in the end and to deliver his heroine a sentimentally happy ending that isn't supported by the novel itself. A gentle bildungsroman that could have used a little more bite. This could be an incredibly sad story were it not for Ryan's ability to infuse the irony of Irish humor into its darkest corners. Lights glimmer just as the story fades to black. His expert storytelling and the strength and resilience of his characters make this so much more than just another Irish family saga. Highly recommended. Short vignette-style chapters sometimes disrupt the flow, though each of the characters shimmers with life. Overall, this is glorious and moving. PrêmiosDistinctionsNotable Lists
"You'll never truly understand love until you've read Donal Ryan: a searing, jubilant story about four generations of women and the fierce devotion that binds them together The Aylward women of Nenagh, County Tipperary, Ireland, are mad about each other, but you wouldn't always think it. You'd have to know them to know that-in spite of what the neighbors might say about raised voices and dramatic scenes-their house is a place of peace, filled with love, a refuge from the sadness and cruelty of the world. Their story begins at an end and ends at a beginning. It involves wives and widows, gunrunners and gougers, sinners and saints. It's a story of terrible betrayals and fierce loyalties, of isolation and togetherness, of transgression, forgiveness, desire, and love. Of all the things family can be and all the things it sometimes isn't. The Queen of Dirt Island is an uplifting celebration of fierce, loyal love and the powerful stories that bind generations together"-- Não foram encontradas descrições de bibliotecas. |
Current DiscussionsNenhum(a)Capas populares
Google Books — Carregando... GênerosClassificação decimal de Dewey (CDD)823.92Literature English & Old English literatures English fiction Modern Period 2000-Classificação da Biblioteca do Congresso dos E.U.A. (LCC)AvaliaçãoMédia:
É você?Torne-se um autor do LibraryThing. |