Elderly Amish widows, Ettie and her sister, Elsa-May, settle down for a comfortable Christmas night not knowing they're in for a surprise. One by one guests arrive claiming they've been invited to a 'Christmas dinner they'll never forget.'Among the guests are Ettie's estranged daughter, Myra, and the retired Detective Crowley.When a man is found dead in the widows' front yard, Crowley immediately takes over and determines that the man has been murdered.Myra recognizes the dead man as her enemy, Earl Fuller. Crowley soon learns that two more people in the house wanted Earl out of the way.Can Ettie and Elsa-May find out who sent out those Christmas invitations?Will the sisters be able to find the real killer and prove that Myra had nothing to do with the man's death?