The second book in The Tide Child trilogy DID NOT DISAPPOINT! RJ Barker is a wonderful storyteller, I am so glad I discovered this author.

"Call of the Bone Ships" is very different in both scope and tone from The Bone Ships. There is still plenty of maritime adventures and sea battles. But here, we go to very dark places, there is grief and sacrifice, loss and scary fanaticism. There is less swashbuckling and more pain, there is always a price to pay for every victory. The stakes are higher. The characters grow and change through pain and hardship and we see a side to some of them we had not seen before.

Unlike the first book, this one ends with a cliffhanger. I wish authors would stop doing that. Hmm, but then again, maybe not ;))) ( )

I never thought I could enjoy a trilogy set almost entirely upon the sea. But this is just fantastic. The narrative style and creative POVs have kept me hooked and wanting more. Haven't been bored yet, and that is really saying something! I'd like a bit more character development, but it's there, if you look. Also, the way this thing is put together is genius. I'm taking notes, Mr. Barker!

Read it. ( )

I never thought I could enjoy a trilogy set almost entirely upon the sea. But this is just fantastic. The narrative style and creative POVs have kept me hooked and wanting more. Haven't been bored yet, and that is really saying something! I'd like a bit more character development, but it's there, if you look. Also, the way this thing is put together is genius. I'm taking notes, Mr. Barker!

Read it. ( )

Lucky Meas’s mother, the leader of the Hundred Isles, wants her “dead” daughter, and Meas is fueled by her anger at the severe mistreatment of her people and will do anything to bring her mother down.

Call of the Bone Ships is a stunning sequel to The Bone Ships. It picks up some time after the events in the first book, but it was easy to get back into the gentle rocking of Tide Child and the routines of his crew. I really loved the first book, so was eager to read the second. The middle book in a trilogy is not usually known to be the most exciting, but this one had me breathlessly reading as quickly as I could to find out what happens next.

The Plot: Chock Full of Adventures
When Tide Child comes to the rescue of a merchant brownbone ship, his crew is shocked and angered to discover it full of ill-treated dead or nearly dead people and guillame called Windshorn. Wanting to know why, and discover where they were being taken, especially after news of the safe haven they and others had created has been destroyed, they make their way into the heart of the Hundred Isles.

Leaving Bernshulme worse off than when they arrived, they do manage to pick up a lead. Danger and death, though, are never far away for a ship of the dead. Though it does answer many questions, all of them horrifying and none of them leading to anything good, especially when Shipwife Meas’s mother is involved.

I have to admit I was a little lost and wondering where the story could possibly be going for about the first quarter. While I loved being back on Tide Child and on the high seas, I just couldn’t fathom what the second installment in the trilogy could be about. It felt like a series of events setting something up, but I could neither tie it into the first book nor figure out what this book was about. But, once I did, I couldn’t read fast enough to find out how it was all going to unfold.

Full of adventure, danger, betrayal, and secrets, Call of the Bone Ships absolutely delivered a breathtaking story. Neither the crew nor the reader ever seems to have a chance to catch their breath. It’s unrelenting, but really moves the story along. There are many threads running through this story, but they’re so perfectly and tightly twined that it’s easy to follow them, though I felt there were some great surprises, especially in the characters, who really make the book come alive.

Ultimately, though, Call of the Bone Ships is more than just a daughter trying to undermine and bring down her mother, more than what the return of the keyshans means for the Hundred Isles. It’s all about Joron Twiner, Meas’s second-in-command. It’s about his transformation through loss and the unrelenting pushes for him to be more, to grow, to learn, to be seen as worthy not just by Meas but by the crew. This is not an easy story for Joron. It tries to kill him several times and throws up barrier after barrier, so it beautifully details his transformation and how he slowly starts to come into his own.

The Characters: Broken and Built Back
It’s the characters that really make this story for me, both in the first and second books. As a motley crew sentenced to death, there are cliques and crewmembers who like some and hate others. I imagine it makes for a very interesting time on the seas. At the same time, Meas has been whipping them into shape and creating a truly Fleet ship. I loved those who were loyal to her and hated those who weren’t. While the first book felt like it focused more on the story and the world, this one felt like it focused more on further developing the main characters and crafting great relationships, though some of them just broke my heart.

Joron hurt me the most. He was just starting to get comfortable, to be used to Meas wearing his Shipwife hat, and this book literally and figuratively tore him apart. It left him in serious emotional and physical pain that was so hard to read, but, I think, is meant to build him into a much better man than he was when he’s first introduced in the first book. But he loses so much, and it’s hard and heart breaking.

But Guillame is wonderful as usual. A truly unique avian creature, it has power of the winds. In Call of the Bone Ships the reader really comes to learn what sets Guillame apart from the other guillame. The relationship between Guillame and Joron is my favorite. It’s strange, but it works, and there’s clearly an affection on both sides.

The Setting: Seas and Ship
In a world divided between the Hundred Isles and the Gaunt Islands, there’s a massive amount of sea. Much of the story is set on the ships necessary for traveling between islands, but a good deal is also set on land. It was great to be back on Tide Child and a lot of fun wandering the different islands.

The islands did blur together a bit. There isn’t too much to distinguish some of them, though the ones carrying a significant population were unique from the others, like Bernshulme and especially Sleighthulme. The other islands made me think of warm sand and thick jungles, so it was really only the events that took place, outside of all the fighting, that informed me of which island they were on for which event.

But my favorite location was Tide Child. It’s own microcosm, the crew has formed their own family and their own cliques. What I loved about this installment in the trilogy is that the bonds between them grow stronger, they become a tighter crew with a single loyalty. It was hard to read through its transformation, but necessary to create a stable deck for Joron to stand on.

As usual, my favorite thing about this series is how immersed I was in the world. I loved pretending to be out on the sea, to be on the decks of a bustling ship with adventure and certain death around the corner. Even when I wasn’t reading I found myself having internal exclamations of “Skearith’s Eye!” Both a little scary and a lot amusing, I think it safe to say I really love this world.

Overall: A Stunning Sequel
I loved The Bone Ships and now I also love Call of the Bone Ships. While I did feel a little confused at the beginning, the story quickly came together. Full of horrors, death, and blood, it also pushed the characters as far as it dared so they could come out on the other side to face what the last book has to throw at them. I adore this world and love the characters, though some of the story lines just broke my heart, and I can’t wait to see how the trilogy concludes. I’ll also be sad to see it end, but am dying to know what happens next.


Thank you to Angela Man and Orbit for a review copy. All opinions expressed are my own. ( )

Another slice of brilliantly-realised maritime fantasy that delivers more sea-borne hijinks, mysterious magic and shipboard friction whilst raising the stakes. It’s a hell of a ride (literally, frequently) and taken as a whole it’s thrilling. The characters are compelling and unpredictable and caught at my heartstrings in unexpected ways. The many-layered plot introduces new threats and ever darker secrets. The tightly-focused action scenes are brilliant, reduced to the desperate view of one man at the heart of the maelstrom and delivered in sentences as short and laboured as Joron’s breath.

But for all the heart-stopping action, Call felt surprisingly slow-paced while I was reading it. There’s a lot of sailing for very little getting anywhere (an accurate portrayal of travel by tall ship, I realise), interspersed with intermittent drama that gets the blood racing again. I’m tempted to call it episodic, although perhaps it’s more apt to accuse it of ebbing and flowing like the tide. Either way, it took a long time for the carefully-constructed elements to coalesce into a big picture that finally felt as urgent as book one’s straightforwardly dramatic ‘save the last sea dragon’ pitch. Once it does, Call of the Bone Ships is fierce and atmospheric, pushing the stakes ever higher as we discover more about the Thirteenbern’s plan and the secrets of the gullaime. And in retrospect, it’s magnificent, a book that begs to be reread (which I plan to do ahead of reading The Bone Ship’s Wake).

So: very much a middle book, but a good one.

Full review

I received a free copy from the publisher in exchange for an honest review ( )