Excellent! Extremely well researched and cited for easy reference. ( )

This is amazingly well researched. I'll be coming back to it a lot, for sure!

Vine had some good points to make, but he also seemed to make several assumptions and cherry pick some quotes and data throughout. I think most of his points are valid and could have been made more clearly (this book could easily have been much shorter) and would have been stronger without what seemed to be mild exaggerations, anecdotes, and asides. ( )

This is an impressive book, and although Vine's perspective is clear, there's also a careful and constant effort to show the issues objectively and with an eye to what needs to be considered when talking about closing or expanding bases, changing policy, or maintaining the status quo.

First, it's important to note that the research isn't just extensive, but presented clearly and without bias; Vine is open about the things which can't be known for sure, and about the biases felt on various sides of the issue. Where interviews are presented, there's an effort to read between the lines while being true to the nature of each interviewee's response, and attention paid to context and background. Importantly, there are interviews with military officials, American and foreign officials/politicians, average military men and women, and also non-military citizens of foreign countries who live around and work in American bases. At all moments, Vine goes out of his way to show multiple sides of a particular corner of the debate about American bases, and although the statistics and titles are sometimes overwhelming as a reader attempts to take them in (because the numbers and stats are, truly, astounding), everything is presented in such a way that a reader feels as if they're being shown the facts and offered a choice, rather than told what to think.

In truth, the greatest failing of the book may be its title, which gives the impression that the book is far more biased and argumentative than it actually is.

For me, many moments in the book were gut-wrenching, to where I literally felt sick to my stomach--and I'm not sure I can say that this happened to such an extent for any book I've read in the past. Much as I've read about history and politics, and despite the fact that have a graduate degree, much of the history surrounding American bases was new to me, and Vine presents the history in such a plain and straightforward fashion that I had a hard time not being horrified, over and over again. Certainly, other readers won't find as much to surprise them. My husband, who was a history major, was rarely even surprised by some of the things I felt a need to repeat to him; yet, I feel fairly sure that a lot of Americans know about what I did about this issue and the debate surrounding American bases, if not less. Personally, I wish every American would read this book; I'm sure not everyone would come out on the same side of the issue, which is a testament to Vine's careful work here, but the book has such import that it's hard to believe it hasn't gotten more attention, so far as I'm concerned.

If you have an interest in America's bases and/or well-being, or in America's foreign policy or domestic progress, I have to think that you'd find the book worth reading. Obviously, I absolutely recommend it. ( )

David Vine puts forth an interesting and convincing study concerning g the growing social, capital, and political costs of American military investment overseas. The United States blankets the globe with its military presence, a cumbersome relic of WWII and the Cold War. The cost of these bases is growing and it is growing unnoticed by the American population footing the bill. Vine looks at the recent history of American base culture as well as breaking down the costs of maintaining an obsolete and ineffective network of military footholds in foreign countries.
Vine has put together a solid case with strong documentary evidence, access to available budget records, and on-site reporting. His arguments are solid and well-developed though at times it does feel like he is reaching somewhat to make some of his more unique critiques of base culture. His overall position is sound and hard to debate fully. The book looks over the last 60 years of American base culture with evenly distributed attention to each major development in the military foreign presence time frame. The evidence, either due to its classification or the recent developments, is weakest for the last decade but the patterns Vine identifies hold up nevertheless. A strong read that raises more questions than answers. In this case, it is a good thing and American citizens should be directing those questions to our leaders. ( )