Este site usa cookies para fornecer nossos serviços, melhorar o desempenho, para análises e (se não estiver conectado) para publicidade. Ao usar o LibraryThing, você reconhece que leu e entendeu nossos Termos de Serviço e Política de Privacidade . Seu uso do site e dos serviços está sujeito a essas políticas e termos.
Henry VI is the youngest monarch ever to have ascended the English throne and the only English king to have been acknowledged by the French as rightfully King of France. His reign was the third longest since the Norman conquest and he came close to being declared a saint. This masterly study, unparalleled in its informative detail, examines the entire span of the king's reign, from the death of Henry V in 1422, when Henry was only nine months old, to the period of his insanity at the beginning of the Wars of the Roses, his dethronement in 1461 and his murder ten years later. This classic reassessment of the third Lancastrian king is essential reading for anyone interested in the history of fifteenth-century England. The third edition includes an additional chapter on recent research.… (mais)
What kind of biography relegates twenty percent of its subject's life to just two pages?
A nine hundred page biography, that's what.
This is considered the biography of that strange, incompetent, mentally ill, martyred (pick your adjective) monarch, Henry VI -- the only English king to have been deposed twice. Certainly it gives just about every scrap of available information about the period. About the king -- hard to say. There is a lot we don't know about Henry VI (including, notably, the illness that drove him mad. Porphyria? Schizophrenia? There just isn't enough data, although I strongly suspect the latter). If you want to get such information as we have, you can pretty much be sure it's in here.
If you can find it. The book really is too long -- there is too much in here that isn't really about Henry VI. It's a pain to sift. And... it doesn't really illuminate. Take my comment about the book relegating twenty percent of Henry's life to two pages. I'm referring to the ending, from his (first) deposition in 1461 until his murder in 1471. There is no real discussion of what was going on -- just a bare summary of the fact that Henry's wife Margaret of Anjou made a deal to get him back on the throne, and her attempt failed, and afterward, Henry was found conveniently dead. Griffiths doesn't even discuss the oft-repeated canard that Richard III, rather than Edward IV, was responsible for the whole thing -- Richard isn't really mentioned in the whole book.
Ultimately, Griffiths presents much data about, but no insight into, Henry VI. There is desperate need for a good scholarly study of the last Lancastrian king. This isn't it. But maybe you could make it into that study -- if you cut the first 898 pages by about sixty percent, replacing that sixty percent with about a third that amount of analysis, and then increased the last two pages by at least fifty. ( )
Having just passed the half way point, I have stopped reading this book for the moment, as it is taking up too much valuable reading time. It is an immensely detailed (900 pages) academic study of Henry VI's reign, but is too specialised for the general reader in Medieval history (even quite an avid one like me). I can admire the scholarly achievement, but it is just too hard to read through, lacking a narrative drive. I will return to it and try the second half of the book when I next get a late Medieval penchant. ( )
Informação do Conhecimento Comum em inglês.Edite para a localizar na sua língua.
For Margaret Sharp and Charles Ross who first introduced me to Henry VI and those in the University College of Swansea with whom I have studied him since
Primeiras palavras
Informação do Conhecimento Comum em inglês.Edite para a localizar na sua língua.
Preface This book began as a study of the structure of politics during Lancastrian England.
Citações
Últimas palavras
Informação do Conhecimento Comum em inglês.Edite para a localizar na sua língua.
It was left to Henry VI himself now to embark on a vigorous posthumous career as the saintly king of England....
Henry VI is the youngest monarch ever to have ascended the English throne and the only English king to have been acknowledged by the French as rightfully King of France. His reign was the third longest since the Norman conquest and he came close to being declared a saint. This masterly study, unparalleled in its informative detail, examines the entire span of the king's reign, from the death of Henry V in 1422, when Henry was only nine months old, to the period of his insanity at the beginning of the Wars of the Roses, his dethronement in 1461 and his murder ten years later. This classic reassessment of the third Lancastrian king is essential reading for anyone interested in the history of fifteenth-century England. The third edition includes an additional chapter on recent research.
)
Google Books — Carregando...
(2.6)
1
A nine hundred page biography, that's what.
This is considered the biography of that strange, incompetent, mentally ill, martyred (pick your adjective) monarch, Henry VI -- the only English king to have been deposed twice. Certainly it gives just about every scrap of available information about the period. About the king -- hard to say. There is a lot we don't know about Henry VI (including, notably, the illness that drove him mad. Porphyria? Schizophrenia? There just isn't enough data, although I strongly suspect the latter). If you want to get such information as we have, you can pretty much be sure it's in here.
If you can find it. The book really is too long -- there is too much in here that isn't really about Henry VI. It's a pain to sift. And... it doesn't really illuminate. Take my comment about the book relegating twenty percent of Henry's life to two pages. I'm referring to the ending, from his (first) deposition in 1461 until his murder in 1471. There is no real discussion of what was going on -- just a bare summary of the fact that Henry's wife Margaret of Anjou made a deal to get him back on the throne, and her attempt failed, and afterward, Henry was found conveniently dead. Griffiths doesn't even discuss the oft-repeated canard that Richard III, rather than Edward IV, was responsible for the whole thing -- Richard isn't really mentioned in the whole book.
Ultimately, Griffiths presents much data about, but no insight into, Henry VI. There is desperate need for a good scholarly study of the last Lancastrian king. This isn't it. But maybe you could make it into that study -- if you cut the first 898 pages by about sixty percent, replacing that sixty percent with about a third that amount of analysis, and then increased the last two pages by at least fifty. (