Replies to Messages on Author Photos Not Working

Trying to reply to comment gets error.

>1 davidgn:

Might have been a momentary glitch. I can see your comment fine. I was also able to add a comment with no problem (as it was a test, I have deleted it now).

Yes, I think this was a temporary issue, can you verify >1 davidgn:? Thanks.

The message I was attempting to reply to was deleted, so can't verify one way or another, but closing.

Closed

Okay, let us know if it crops up again? Thanks.

Yep. Can't reply to lilithcat on the page. https://www.librarything.com/pic/8715163

>7 davidgn:

I wonder if the fact that that was a private message is at all relevant. I see your reply on my comment wall, but not on the image page.

>8 lilithcat: And I was able to reply from my wall, but not from the image page.

>9 davidgn: I'm going to test this with you, if that's alright. I'll try posting both public and private messages on two images of yours, if you can try replying from both the image page and your comment wall and let me know what results you get for which messages?

ETA: okay, commented on both https://www.librarything.com/pic/5413793 and https://www.librarything.com/pic/8715163

I had all four fail when I tried yesterday. And also couldn't respond to conceptdawg's comment on https://www.librarything.com/pic/8715163. Get the yellow bar with "Something has gone wrong."

>11 davidgn: Argh, that's frustrating. Okay.

What operating system and web browser are you using? I assume you have javascript enabled? Do you have any browser add-ons or extensions enabled?

Finally, would you mind trying a public and private comment on one of my test account's images here: https://www.librarything.com/pic/8376829? I'll see if I can reproduce. Thank you!

ChromeOS, Running Chrome Version 97.0.4692.102 (Official Build) (64-bit)
Nothing exotic running on extensions, and tested again after disabling just to be sure.

Also fails with Brave 1.34.81, Chromium 97.0.4692.99
(which reports OS as Android 9 Build R97/14324.72.0)

No access to other devices just now.

Okay, I was at least able to reproduce inability to reply to image comments from my test account, thanks for that.

I was testing in incognito mode on my Chrome (v. 97) browser (Mac OS Monterey, 12.1).

Here's what I'm seeing after submitting both replies and the dev console (for conceptDawg to take a look, I think):

Bump on this old bug. I got the same error attempting to reply to someone's comment on one of my images. I can post an original comment on my image itself, to me, but I cannot post a reply to the commenter.

Verified for me.

Fixed. Finally.