Foto do autor

Aspen Matis

Autor(a) de Girl in the Woods: A Memoir

2 Works 238 Membros 7 Reviews

About the Author

Aspen Matis work has appeared in the New York Times, Tin House, Psychology Today, Salon, and Marie Claire. She lives in Greenwich Village and is working on a new book.

Obras de Aspen Matis

Etiquetado

Conhecimento Comum

Membros

Resenhas

Have you ever read a book where you sorta know you shouldn't rate it five stars because it is misleading to others, yet you LOVED every minute of reading it? No? Well that's what happened to me with this book.

Let me share the flaws first so you are forewarned.

1. This book is like a COPY of Wild by Cheryl Strayed. If you liked Wild, you will like this one. If you hated, Wild, back away slowly. Basically the plot is "girl hikes Pacific Coast Trail and finds her inner strength". Sound familiar.

2. I hated the author pretty much the entire time I read the book. Ok, hate may be a strong word, but I think she has a narcissistic personality disorder. Or something. Her judgement is sorely lacking. Even for a 19 year old.

Ok, so you are forewarned.

But on the flip side, the girl can write a story.

I was pretty much riveted the entire time. Her descriptions of the outdoors were beautiful and vivid. But they didn't overwhelm the book. I just thought her writing was very engaging and accessible. I could have read the book in one sitting, no problem.

And okay, I love a good tale of outdoor adventure. I just do.

EDIT: Ok, I really couldn't let this book stand with a five star rating. After a few days passed, I just realized that even though I loved reading it, the book is truly not original, and the writing, while completely engaging, isn't really enough to merit the rating either. But it is a very entertaining read, so if historically I gave out stars for the entertainment factor alone, it might have earned the fifth one.
… (mais)
 
Marcado
Anita_Pomerantz | outras 5 resenhas | Mar 23, 2023 |
HOW did the author remember so many, MANY details in terms of color, texture, etc., etc.???? She is enormously precise in the pictures she paints as she seems to be living-in-the-moment throughout the book. I particularly liked the last few chapters when she analyzes how she wound up where she "is." It would be curious to see if and when she and Justin ever cross paths again to see what they each discover about each other...what has changed?
 
Marcado
nyiper | May 26, 2020 |
Interesting, but it got a little tiresome reading about her back and forth between wanting a man to walk with and wanting to walk alone. Girl could not make up her mind. I don't blame her but it got exhausting to read.
1 vote
Marcado
Katie_Roscher | outras 5 resenhas | Jan 18, 2019 |
I tried very desperately to like this one. I like women who set out on the trails but Aspen came across as a very spoiled rich girl who had no sense of self or her privilege. That doesn't change at all throughout the book.
1 vote
Marcado
DearRosieDear | outras 5 resenhas | May 8, 2018 |

You May Also Like

Estatísticas

Obras
2
Membros
238
Popularidade
#95,270
Avaliação
3.2
Resenhas
7
ISBNs
12

Tabelas & Gráficos