Picture of author.

About the Author

Winner of a 1990 Pulitzer Prize for explanatory journalism, Steve Coll has been managing editor of The Washington Post since 1998 and covered Afghanistan as the Post's South Asia bureau chief between 1989 and 1992. Coll is the author of four books, He lives with his wife and three children in mostrar mais Maryland mostrar menos

Includes the name: Steve Coll

Image credit: Courtesy of the Pulitzer Prizes.

Obras de Steve Coll

Associated Works

The Best Business Writing 2013 (2013) — Contribuinte — 14 cópias

Etiquetado

Conhecimento Comum

Membros

Resenhas

Until September 11th, Afghanistan would have been a pretty obscure area in which to be a subject matter expert. Afterwards, of course, we all found out a lot about the Taliban and the Northern Alliance and the Pashtun people, but honestly it was all so much so fast that I know I (and probably lots of other people) ended up more confused than anything else. Steve Coll's Ghost Wars tells the story of American involvement in Afghanistan, beginning around the Cold War and ending on September 10th of 2001, and it tied together a lot of the dangling strings that American involvement in Afghanistan after September 11th left me with. Deeply researched and very informative, this is a thorough portrait of how we got to where we are.

Geopolitics in Central and South Asia turns out to be really complicated! The CIA's involvement began as a response to the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, and the desire to have a firewall against the spread of Communism. It continued even after their withdrawal to both prevent a re-invasion and because of the US's relationship with Pakistan, which saw Afghanistan as a firewall of its own against India. And then there's Saudi Arabia, which had its own complicated relationships with not only Afghanistan, where it exported its brand of intense Islam, but of course the United States, as well as Pakistan. It's very messy, and trying to learn about it feels like intensely watching a magician to try to discern the sleight-of-hand...you've got your eye on one part of the stage, but to really understand the whole picture, there's something going on somewhere else that's going to be important to the way it comes together. And then of course there's the relationship of the CIA to their own government and the American public, which had a very real impact on how much, and how effectively, the CIA was able to actually do.

It becomes patently obvious while reading this book that there was very likely no one single factor that would have prevented terror attacks from taking place on American soil. There were too many forces that were all coming into alignment for it to be avoided entirely. But it does raise (without proselytizing about) issues that might have kept the particular 9/11 attack from coming to fruition that are, of course, all too easy to see in hindsight: US funding for the Northern Alliance, more willingness to heed the increasingly frenzied warnings that al-Qiada was eager and capable of an attack, a more forceful relationship with Pakistan, etc after etc. Coll doesn't try to lay blame at anyone in particular's feet, but he's also not interested in massaging or obscuring information that would let anyone claim absolution, either. He's interested in presenting as full a picture as he reasonably can, and he accomplishes that.

Considering that it's nonfiction designed to reach a mass audience, it's about as comprehensive as anyone should want/expect. In fact, if I'm being honest, its biggest flaw is that there is so much information being presented that it's overly dense. It's hard, because it never came off like there were details being dumped extraneously so it's not that it just needed a more diligent editor, but the reality is that it's a fact-heavy story, with a lot of new people/situations needing to be introduced to the reader with sufficient context, so the result is a book that ends up feeling kind of like a slog even though it's interesting and relevant. And honestly, I prefer that kind of approach to one that cuts out important bits to dumb itself down for the reader. To sum up, I do recommend this book if you're interesting in learning about the history of the US in Afghanistan. It's well-written and a very good resource. But if fact-intensive non-fiction isn't your jam and this isn't a subject of particular interest to you, there's no need to torture yourself.
… (mais)
 
Marcado
ghneumann | outras 33 resenhas | Jun 14, 2024 |
Who created Al-Quaeda? Would you believe it was the CIA? I do. After reading this book.
 
Marcado
MylesKesten | outras 33 resenhas | Jan 23, 2024 |
Make no mistake, this book is not a small undertaking. The density of information, whilst impressive, is tiring. I found it best to read in chunks, between other books. Fortunately, each chapter stands alone rather well, whilst still bringing the complex threads of the ExxonMobil (post Exxon Valdez) story together in a cogent manner. It took a while to read through it in this way, but I don't think the experience suffered for it.

Steve Coll brings a very high level of journalistic expertise to the table and it shows. This book is astonishingly well researched, pretty much every assertion made is backed up with citations from sources such as interviews carried out specifically for this book, FOIA requests and Wikileaks cables. Coll maintains a relatively objective voice throughout as well, something I wasn't expecting so much. I was anticipating something rather more overtly damning than is presented, though there can be no doubt as to the conclusions Coll expects you to draw, both in relation to 'Big Oil' generally and ExxonValdez in particular. This book is a fascinating insight into that world and it's machinations. Recommended for those with the interest and patience to stick it out.… (mais)
 
Marcado
laurence_gb | outras 7 resenhas | Jul 30, 2023 |
Heavy in details of all the political incompetence, unavoidable errors, and easy-to-make mistakes that compounded in the lead up to 9/11. The similarities to what Afghanistan looks like now and the public facing policy of the current POTUS administration makes it all feel so much worse.Â

Also a really good portrayal of Massoud, but definitely biased in his favor. Author has a noticeable soft spot for the CIA.
 
Marcado
aepCaomhan | outras 33 resenhas | Jul 20, 2023 |

Listas

Prêmios

You May Also Like

Associated Authors

Estatísticas

Obras
8
Also by
1
Membros
4,254
Popularidade
#5,912
Avaliação
4.1
Resenhas
67
ISBNs
81
Idiomas
7
Favorito
6

Tabelas & Gráficos